And it’s a really fair question to ask here because as a small business, you’re trying to compete with big brands, and you’re trying to compete with local small brands, and sometimes, you’re competing with other businesses (large and small), something on a regional scale, and beyond. But there’s a lot of competition out there, and a lot of people talk about owning a business like there’s one “better” path, and that’s usually where things start getting weird.
So, starting from scratch gets treated like the bold, exciting, respectable option, like that’s the version with all the glory attached to it. Buying a business, meanwhile, can get framed like taking a shortcut, which is kind of funny when buying the wrong one can still wreck somebody’s sleep schedule, bank account, and patience just fine.
So yeah, this really comes down to fit. Which might be the most generic answer, as this really does vary from person to person, but theres some other things to think about here though.
Starting from Zero is Great if You Actually Want Zero
And yes, that’s the first thing to get honest about. Again, it’s not for everyone (which is totally fine), some people genuinely love the blank page. They like coming up with the concept, shaping the brand, testing ideas, fixing mistakes, and slowly turning something invisible into something real. But clearly that’s a lot of work, that’s so much patience, there’s trial and error, theres a very high risk of failure there too.
And the problem is that part gets romanticized way too much. Starting from scratch can be rewarding, sure, but it can also feel like constantly making decisions with incomplete information while money drips out in this constant flow. Some people can handle it, some are totally okay with that and can handle the risk, but not everyone can, of course.
Buying Can Make More Sense for People Who Want Traction
For some people, building from the ground up is the smartest choice for them, and others will think that buying is the best way to go about it. Again, one isn’t better than the other. But with buying a business, at least, that business has customers already, there are already some systems in place, already have income coming through, and already have a name people recognize.
Clearly theres some benefits there, and it can help to just look through listings of businesses for sale, see what’s out there, see what would work for you, see the information (and ask questions) to the business owner. Theres a lot of transparency (and legal protection) from buying a business that you don’t get when you’re just starting from the ground up.
But What Matches Your Energy?
Well, not everybody’s in the same season of life, and not everybody has the same appetite for building something from the studs up. A person juggling family life, financial pressure, burnout, or a full-time job may not have endless energy for the chaos of a start-up. So, for one person wanting a quick escape, they might want to buy, which might be the most realistic. Again, theres no right or wrong answer here.
Your Strengths Matter More than the Fantasy
And fantasies can be fun to think about, but they don’t always come to life. Some people are creators. They’re good at spotting ideas, shaping something original, and getting it off the ground. Other people are much better at improving what’s already there. They’re stronger with structure, systems, decision-making, tidying up loose ends, and making an existing operation run better than it did before. So yeah, you need to be pretty realistic here too.
Photo by Amina Filkins on Pexels
